Over ten years ago (perhaps in 2004) my friend Michael Schwartz and his fiance Brandy showed me a game called 1000 Blank White Cards (which was originally developed in 1996). Players write pretty much whatever they want on the cards (sometimes while playing the game), and the winner is generally determined by whoever gets the most points. Players take turns playing one card. I had a lot of fun playing the game, but I didn’t like the focus on points. I wanted there to be a different win condition.
Nightmare Crazy Eights (March 2004)
1000 Blank Cards inspired me to develop my own card game where cards would do all kinds of creative and interesting things (with limited success). In March 2004 I developed a game based loosely on Crazy Eights. Let’s call it “Nightmare Crazy.” Players would take turns discarding a card as long as it had the same rank or color as the top card of the discard pile. Whenever a card was discarded, you could also play the card for an effect (just like in variations of Crazy Eights), and every card had an effect.
The game was also somewhat inspired by Magic: the Gathering because so many cards from that game also had creative abilities. I knew cards could do pretty much limitless things based on my experiences with Magic. The card to the right is Alien Invasion featuring an image from the movie Independence Day. Note that the card frame is used by Magic: the Gathering, and the card frames were available on the Internet. I had already made several of my own Magic cards at that point in time. Take a look at some other cards that were included in Nightmare Crazy Eights:
The image used for Alternate Personality is from Fight Club, Godzilla is from one of the Godzilla movies, and the image used for Merchant is by Charles Bargue.
Nightmare Crazy Eights II (December 2004)
In December 2004 I had an idea for a new version of Nightmare Crazy Eights — I could give cards various costs, and some of the cards could end up being very powerful (but harder to play for the effect). I also wanted to try out a lot of other fun ideas. I made my own card frames for Nightmare Crazy Eights II, but they are still closely based on the Magic: the Gathering card frame.
Nightmare Crazy Eights II was probably worse than the original version because having costs made the cards hard to play. The result was that very few card abilities were often used when playing the game. Even so, I decided to fix the game earlier this year because a lot of the cards are quite fun when they work. The main way I fixed the game is to reduce or eliminate the costs. However, I also updated the game to use the Crazier Eights rules. The card to the right, Sun, is based on the desktop wallpaper found here. Take a look at some of the other cards:
The image used for Poker is by C. M. Coolidge and can be found here. The Cabbit and space ship card art is from Tenchi Muyo. and was inspired by the flip mechanic used in the Kamigawa Magic set, which came out around the same time.
Nightmare Crazy Eights III (July 2007)
I thought of some new ideas for a Nightmare Crazy Eights game. I wanted to simplify the game, I wanted all the ranks and suits used for a regular deck of cards, and I wanted to eliminate a lot of the costs (or all of the costs). I considered using the cards for multiple different card games. I had two different versions of the cards, but I only printed out one of them and it wasn’t as good as I hoped. I should have tried to fix it up, but I was also working on some other game projects at that point. The image used for the card on the right-hand side was from Invasion of the Saucer Men. The card frame is based on a card frame that might have been used for another card game someone was developing. I don’t know if the card game was ever completed or what it was called.
Crazier Eights (November 2013)
For some reason I was thinking about Nightmare Crazy and I realized that there could be a better way to play the game: Cards could be discarded as usual, but the cards would then have no effect. Players would take turns playing any card for an effect and discarding a card (which would still have to have the appropriate color or rank). Whenever a card would be played for an effect, the player would draw a card to replace it. I felt like the new rules were a big success. Players could play a card for an effect every turn, and the card effects could be quite strong without leading to any major problems. One issue with the game was that certain cards were a bit confusing. I wanted a card that would make you draw a few cards, then put that many cards back on top of the draw pile, but players had to also remember to draw a card whenever they played a card for an effect. It was some months later that I thought of a better set of rules — players would take turns drawing a card, playing any one card for an effect, and discarding one card. That solved any issues there could be with confusion. Another thing that happened is that I decided that the first version of the game should be quite simple, so there are no costs. Also, the first version of the game has the same cards in every color — There is a blue Trade, a red Trade, a green Trade, a yellow Trade, etc. Now it is June (approximately seven months later), and I have thought of several other ways to improve the game in those several months of playtesting.
The story continues. See part 2 here.